DO IT YOURSELF: How to Make Meringues

Looking MUCH more edible!

Before you read this post, read the how NOT to make meringues post. Heed my warnings!

So on Friday night I’d made terrible, terrible meringues for Passover. On Sunday morning I decided to try again. Beat my losing streak. And I happened to be going to an Easter soiree, so I wanted to make good ones and not poison the whole group. Party foul.

First of all, I wanted to avoid using coffee in my new recipe. I was scarred. So I consulted one of my favorite cooking blogs, Smitten Kitchen. Her recipe is for a crunchier meringue (not my bag), but luckily it directed me to the traditional baking directions for a more pavlova-esque meringue. (They had me at pavlova.)

I didn’t think Smitten Kitchen’s yield would be large enough (just 2 egg whites), so I sort of combined the two sites’ recipes. This involved purchasing cream of tartar, parchment (not just for Torahs!), another baking sheet (no Pyrex unless called for) and crushed pecans (I already had chocolate chips).

The key ingredient: Parchment.

I was a little worried about bending the rules again, but this worked out okay (and yielded about 36 meringues).

-3 large egg whites

-1/4 tsp cream of tarter

-1/8 tsp salt (in case the extra cream of tarter was salty?)

-1 tsp vanilla extract (I think)

-3/4 cup sugar (both recipes called for that amount)

-1 cup tiny chocolate chips

-About 1/4 cup pecans? I forget. Maybe more.

I added the vanilla when Smitten Kitchen directed — when you add the cream of tarter and salt. I also liked that they didn’t tell you times and settings after all — it’s easier to just go by, when the eggs are foamy, do this. Or when they have soft peaks, do that. And you can definitely tell when it’s done, because it’s hard to keep mixing.


This time I folded in chocolate chips and pecans, hoping nobody was allergic.

Love this spatula thingy.

And then I scooped them onto parchment, and 3 egg whits turned out to be so much that I needed all sorts of backup pans.

Call in the backup pans!

They came out looking like beautiful, beautiful clouds. Mission accomplished.

Ready to float away.

Another shot! Just to celebrate them not poisoning me this time!


They were melt-in-your-mouth. And while they weren’t exactly HUGE competition for Funfetti cupcakes with really adorable frosting, I will say that my friends were VERY impressed that ALL those meringues came from just THREE egg whites.

Inside view! Where the mix-ins are hiding.

I ate the leftovers for breakfast for several days (I thought they were better 2nd day), because — hey! Egg whites! They’re what’s for breakfast. I will say that the meringues did smell a little odd. Like — eggy? So I tried not to take any big whiffs. They still TASTED good.

Today I made a smaller batch for yet another party (for my friend who goes to PASTRY SCHOOL — COOL!), and I used the Smitten Kitchen proportions/recipe, but replaced the nuts (nut sure if anybody had allergies) with a little more than a tablespoon of instant coffee. So it’s a mocha flavor, I guess. The yield for 2 egg whites was 24 — not bad! (I actually counted these, and did the math from to approximate the 36 from 3 egg whites.) I still did the 1.5 hour bake at 200 degrees.

Just one manageable tray!

That was pre-baking. This is post:

Are you gonna be edible?

This batch seems a bit overcooked, but they haven’t had a chance to sit for an hour. Maybe the coffee just isn’t a good idea… or maybe it’s too bitter for my taste. Or maybe all of the above. (EDIT: They needed to sit for a while. Baking science!)

Friend or foe?

We’ll see how I feel in a little while…


Follow us on Twitter / Fan us on Facebook

One thought on “DO IT YOURSELF: How to Make Meringues

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s